📚

Facebook Needs to Change Its Relationship Status With Music From “It’s Complicated” to “It’s Love”

August 8, 2010

Facebook is fucking up music big time. Here’s why and what ought to be done about it.

Do you know anyone who does not like music? Well. So of the now more than 500 million people on Facebook, quite a few must be into music, right? Yet to date, Facebook has done its very best to make this relationship, in its own words, “complicated”.

The Problem: Musicians and Listeners, But No Music

According to AllFacebook, of the 30 most popular brands on Facebook, nine are musicians or bands (with “Music” as such being number ten). People on Facebook, as if any proof was needed, like music and like to connect to musicians on Facebook.

Yet, these musicians’ pages lack what they need most: a decent music player. Let’s make this clear: Facebook fails to offer to some of its top brands a reasonable tool to present their core asset: music. And more importantly: Facebook fails to offer to its users the music experience they deserve.

What Facebook currently offers as a “Music Player” would put any tiny music startup to shame, let alone a company that has 500 million customers. You can hit play to listen to a song, that’s about it. What’s more, it’s not even stable, it gets stuck way too often. There is no better way to tell people: We don’t care about music on our site.

Can Facebook afford to not care about music? No. They’d better make it a core part of the Facebook experience. Now, not later.

The Reasoning: Music Is Social

Facebook is so successful largely because they bring together people and engage them in activities that are inherently social. Sharing information about what you are doing and thinking: social. Showing around photos of you and your friends: social. Playing games: social. Planning events: social.

Listening to music and recommending the best bits to our friends has been social ever since. Way back, we recorded mixtapes to please our friends and to impress girls. Now, it’s playlists and single songs that we recommend to others. It’s hardly surprising that all big music services on the web have implemented social features that allow to share music with friends. A good part of that sharing happens via Facebook. Yet the music action still happens anywhere but on Facebook. Also, ironically, while people have migrated in masses from MySpace to Facebook, music hasn’t. People connent to their favourite musicians on Facebook, but if they want to listen to a couple of songs of a specific artist or band without any big hassle, MySpace is still the place to go. Sad, but true. A music player done right by Facebook would pull the plug on MySpace.

It’s about time Facebook puts itself on the map.

The Solution: Learn From Bandcamp

For a start, it doesn’t even take much. Give musicians a fully functional, well designed player to present their songs. Let people embed songs from these players in their status updates and have them create playlists they can share with their friends. Users will start sharing music content from within Facebook rather than embedding external content (YouTube videos, Mp3s from blogs, etc.), boosting engagement on Facebook and directing more fans to the musicians’ Facebook pages.

To make the player attractive to both users and content owners, Facebook should have a butcher’s at how Bandcamp does things right. Buy them or, if not, watch closely and learn. Bandcamp offers a clean and simple music player that can be embedded anywhere across the web. And it has a built-in business sales desk, allowing bands to sell their music in a clean and simple process. Bandcamp encourages music sharing, empowers musicians to make a business and gives them detailed insights on how their music is played and shared. So should Facebook.

So, dear Facebook:

Build a music player
– than runs smoothly,
– that can be shared on Facebook and across the web,
– that has a built-in option to buy songs.

It’s a simple step. It will have a huge impact. And you owe it to you users.


Interface mockups

This is what Facebook’s music player could look like. I’m a writer, not a designer, so let’s argue about my ideas and not my mockups.

The player, as to be used on musicians pages:

The player, as to be displayed in members’ newsfeeds:

The player, as to be displayed in members’ newsfeeds when expanded:

Hello, nice to meet you. I'm David Bauer. I’m a journalist by training, a product person by conviction, and a generalist at heart. I love complex issues and helping people navigate them. Learn more →

📨 hello@davidbauer.ch 🐦 @davidbauer

Weekly Filet

Thousands of curious minds trust the Weekly Filet for food for thought. Every Friday, I send out a carefully curated set of recommendations on what to read, watch, listen to.

Past work

I have worked for startups and large companies.
As a journalist, strategist, product lead.

I have written stories and strategies.
I have built products and teams.

I have hired, mentored and promoted people.
I have navigated and accelerated transformation.
Pushed for and nurtured culture change.

I have wrangled data and code.
For insights and data visualisations.
Even a series of games.

And a ton of other things that got me excited.

If there’s one thing that connects it all,
it’s my love for connecting dots and trying new things.

🤝
Neue Zürcher Zeitung, The Guardian, Quartz, Republik, Refind, Livingdocs, Radio Free Europe, Der Spiegel, Das Magazin, Tages-Anzeiger, SonntagsZeitung, TagesWoche, Schweizerische Depeschenagentur, Echtzeit Verlag, MAZ Journalistenschule, TEDxZurich, Bluewin, and some more.

You Don't Know Africa
Why newsrooms need storytelling tools and what we’ve learnt building them
78s – bessere Musik
You deserve a smarter reading list — we are building it
A story of drinkers, genocide and unborn girls
You Still Don't Know Africa
Wenn Männer über Männer reden, reden Männer Männern nach
How to Be(come) a Happy Newsletter Writer
You Don't Know African Flags
The simple tool we use to decide what stories to work on at NZZ Visuals
Bookshelf
To compete with the web’s giants, news organisations need to become better at sending people away
Kurzbefehl - Der Kompass für das digitale Leben
Vaxillology
How I Learnt to Code in One Year
Deep Dives
Zum Pi-Tag: Von 3,14159 bis zum derzeitigen Ende von Pi
Dystopia Tracker
Milliarden aus der Fremde
How to Build a Successful Product Strategy
Midterms Results Overview
Euro-Orakel
Dichtestressomat
The End of Journalism in the Digital Age
Never miss any of the most important links, even in a busy week
Wie gut können Sie die Schweiz aus dem Gedächtnis zeichnen?
Vertrauensserie
Lionel Messi
60 Stunden Facebook
Work at the Guardian Data Blog